A Globe-Gazette editorial attempts to link the recent shut down of two refugee resettlement agencies with the deplorable case of immigrant child abuse at the now defunct Agriprocessors slaughterhouse (here).
Child after immigrant child took the witness stand in Waterloo last week to describe abusive working conditions at the former Agriprocessors Inc. plant in Postville..Fourteen- and 15-year-olds testified about back-breaking, low-paying work for Sholom Rubashkin, the former Agriprocessors CEO charged with 83 misdemeanor state child labor law violations. He already has been convicted of massive financial fraud.
He has yet to be tried for immigration law violations federal authorities filed after the biggest immigration raid in Iowa history May 12, 2008. Federal agents removed 390 undocumented workers from the plant, shutting it down…
This is the context for the regrettable closing of Iowa’s Bureau of Refugee Services, the state’s No. 1 manager of legal immigration. Since 1975, this bureau brought 28,000 legal immigrants to Iowa and supported another 10,000 who moved to the state after legally entering the country.
…The U.S. State Department ended its $134,000 annual appropriation for the state office and is choosing to support only national, non-profit resettlement programs.
Also, the state’s No. 2 agency for refugee resettlement is shutting down. Lutheran Social Services of Iowa is ending its resettlement partnership with Catholic Charities that welcomed 483 refugees last year.
That leaves only Catholic Charities, which generously decided Wednesday to continue this ministry alone.
Of course, the national refugee resettlement volag Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society (HIAS), far from condemning the abuses of young immigrants at Agriprocessors, has gone out of its way to call for “fairness” (here) in the sentencing of the diabolical former owner of Agriprocessors, Sholom Rubashkin, whose second trial, this time on child labor violation, was delayed after he was apparently bitten by someone in jail (here).
In the meantime the Globe-Gazette editorial attempts to sell us on the concept that meatpacking plants in Iowa would not be able to run were it not for immigrant labor.
…[the immigration raid on Agriprocessors proved] once again that Iowa’s agriculture economy cannot function without immigrant labor.The work force at every meatpacking plant in the state affirms it. So do the past three Iowa governors, who agree legal immigration is essential for the state’s economic growth, not simply “important” or “a key factor.” While in office, Govs. Terry Branstad, Tom Vilsack and Chet Culver all said Iowa simply cannot grow without legal immigration.
…If history is an indicator, thousands of illegal immigrants will continue to be drawn into the traps set by those like Rubashkin, who federal and state authorities say built a business around exploited illegal immigrants.
Refugee resettlement is an honorable part of Iowa government and faith mission history. It also is a vital part of the state’s economic development.
Isn’t that dangerous when state elites decide that refugee resettlement is not a matter of human rights, rather, is an opportunity to exploit labor for the “economic development” of the state? Are these the same people who look the other way when refugee resettlement agencies, landlords, and employers neglect and abuse refugees?
I guess the editorial board also never considered that the ruthless consolidation in the meatpacking business, and the resulting plunge in wages paid, not to mention the speeding up of the slaughtering process and resultant extreme abuse of livestock, was never a real necessity but was the result of our government’s decision to let private industry do whatever it wanted to do (witness how that same philosophy and process has worked in our financial industry, oil industry, etc.).
By the way, we also just came across photographs of housing conditions for immigrants of the former Agriprocessors (here). As you can see conditions somewhat approximate some of the horrendous and deplorable housing that refugee resettlement agencies have placed refugees in around the country.
Pictures of Agriprocessors’ “campus-style” housing are posted immediately below. Each worker paid $100 per week for a mattress on the floor. Some of these homes had 10 to 12 workers sleeping in them. Many were unfurnished:
This last picture is a mattress and box spring (no bed frame) in a laundry closet. The open pipe on the right is a dryer vent. On the left are the hookups for the washer and dryer.
Workers complained of being assigned a mattress on the floor of moldy basements and of having 3 and sometimes 4 workers per room, 10 to 12 per house.
Each worker paid $100 per week, usually deducted from their paychecks.



