According to an article in the New York Times a dedicated and highly qualified elementary school principal in Burlington, Vt has been let go so that the Burlington School District could qualify for up to $3 million in federal stimulus money for its dozen schools. The school’s student test scores were low allegedly due to a 97 percent poverty rate and large numbers of refugee children, many with little earlier education. Under current federal rules, for a district to qualify, schools with very low test scores must do one of the following: close down; be replaced by a charter (Vermont does not have charters); remove the principal and half the staff; or remove the principal and transform the school.
By all accounts, the school’s principle, Joyce Irvine, was an exemplary leader.
John Mudasigana, one of many recent African refugees whose children attend the high-poverty school, says he is grateful for how Ms. Irvine and her teachers have helped his five children. “Everything is so good about the school,” he said, before taking his daughter Evangeline, 11, into the school’s dental clinic.
Ms. Irvine’s most recent job evaluation began, “Joyce has successfully completed a phenomenal year.” Jeanne Collins, Burlington’s school superintendent, calls Ms. Irvine “a leader among her colleagues” and “a very good principal.”
Beth Evans, a Wheeler teacher, said, “Joyce has done a great job,” and United States Senator Bernie Sanders noted all the enrichment programs, including summer school, that Ms. Irvine had added since becoming principal six years ago.
“She should not have been removed,” Mr. Sanders said in an interview. “I’ve walked that school with her — she seemed to know the name and life history of every child.”
…Ms. Irvine wasn’t removed by anyone who had seen her work (often 80-hour weeks) at a school where 37 of 39 fifth graders were either refugees or special-ed children and where, much to Mr. Mudasigana’s delight, his daughter Evangeline learned to play the violin. here
Unfortunate for schools with already low test scores, and that receive a large influx of refugee students, rules do not allow schools to leave out refugee students from testing. Refugee students have to take tests, in English, that they are not prepared for and have no way of understanding.
Under No Child rules, a student arriving one day before the state math test must take it. Burlington is a major resettlement area, and one recent September, 28 new students — from Somalia, Ethiopia, Kenya, Sudan — arrived at Wheeler and took the math test in October.
Ms. Irvine said that in a room she monitored, 15 of 18 randomly filled in test bubbles. The math tests are word problems. A sample fourth-grade question: “Use Xs to draw an array for the sum of 4+4+4.” Five percent of Wheeler’s refugee students scored proficient in math.
About half the 230 students are foreign-born, collectively speaking 30 languages. Many have been traumatized; a third see one of the school’s three caseworkers. During Ms. Irvine’s tenure, suspensions were reduced to 7 last year, from 100.
Students take the reading test after one year in the country. Ms. Irvine tells a story about Mr. Mudasigana’s son Oscar and the fifth-grade test.
Oscar needed 20 minutes to read a passage on Neil Armstrong landing his Eagle spacecraft on the moon; it should have taken 5 minutes, she said, but Oscar was determined, reading out loud to himself.
The first question asked whether the passage was fact or fiction. “He said, ‘Oh, Mrs. Irvine, man don’t go on the moon, man don’t go on the back of eagles, this is not true,’ ” she recalled. “So he got the five follow-up questions wrong — penalized for a lack of experience.”
Thirteen percent of foreign-born students, 4 percent of special-ed students and 23 percent of the entire school scored proficient in reading.
Indiana Senator Richard Lugar has recommended that refugee students be kept separate from other students until they can catch up (here), and not be tested until then so that their scores will not negatively impact schools’ ratings. What worries me about that is the opposite and equally damaging practice in which refugee students receive low-quality teaching, as noted in an article about schools in Buffalo here. Although the Senator is recommending that the federal government require that schools use “best practices” to guide refugee children’s separate but equal programs, how well would the government enforce that?
If the refugee program itself is any guide, not very well I presume.